I know this article will definitely hit some nerves but I want to address the elephant in the room when it comes to choosing cycling clubs for both good and bad. Let’s start with what a bad club looks like. A “bad” cycling club is one that undermines the purpose of group rides which is to train together, to learn from each other, and to enjoy the sport.
Some red flags to watch out for are:
- No-drop policy ignored – If leaders routinely drop riders or the “no-drop” rule is just a formality, it erodes trust and discourages participation.
- Ride leaders prioritize ego over group needs – Choosing the hilliest or most challenging routes for the sake of “showing off” can leave weaker riders behind and create frustration.
- Lack of mutual support – If no one checks on tail-enders, offers help with flats, or regroups to keep everyone in the pack, the ride feels like a solo workout.
- Inconsistent or unbalanced group – If the ride is always at the top riders’ level and no “B group” exists to support newcomers, it’s hard for new members to join and stay.
- Toxic or competitive culture – Rides that feel like a race to the finish line with no shared effort, or where riders are unwilling to help each other, can damage the spirit of the sport.
- Poor communication – If pre-ride briefings don’t match the actual ride, or if route/pacing changes aren’t shared, it breeds confusion and resentment.
- Perceived lack of friendliness – Misinterpreted as unfriendliness, some clubs are actually just competitive or self-reliant, but if there’s no trust or willingness to help, it can still feel isolating.
A bad club can teach bad habits, discourage new riders, and make the sport feel less enjoyable. If you notice these patterns, it’s worth looking for a club that values teamwork, inclusivity, and shared goals over ego or competition.
I’m sorry to say, clubs like these do exist and the problem is that they do not realize the damage they are doing to the cycling community. But just as there are bad clubs, there are good clubs that do foster learning, builds skills, and creates a supportive environment. You can virtually take these red flag indicators and reverse them in exact order to see what a good club looks like.
No matter what your skill level or interest is in cycling, all club rides should feel good at the end of each workout without compromising self-respect or safety to its riders. A suggestion is that you give the club a test ride to see it if meets your expectations. That way, there is no commitment to join if things don’t work out. It’s always a good practice to trust your gut instincts when it comes to choosing a club meaning if the vibes feel good versus feeling wrong, it can save you a lot of frustration in the end so choose wisely my friend.
v/r
Elmer Feick
USA Cycling Coach
EF Cycles
El Paso Bicycle Club 